1. Home
  2. Cape May Gifts

Cape May Gifts

Sort by:
Cape May Sea Gull
Cape May Sea Gull

PLUSH

$ 21.95
Cape May Tri Wave Cap
Cape May Tri Wave Cap

APPAREL

$ 24.99
Cape May Wave and Palm Tree Cap
Cape May Wave and Palm Tree Cap

APPAREL

$ 24.99
Baby Turtle Mug
Baby Turtle Mug

HOUSEWARES

$ 14.95
JERSEY DEVIL SQUISHABLE
JERSEY DEVIL SQUISHABLE

PLUSH

$ 35.00
Cape May Lighthouse
Cape May Lighthouse

Home Decor

$ 9.95
Claudia Vance - Cape May Hydrangeas #10
Claudia Vance - Cape May Hydrangeas #10

Book

$ 14.99
Claudia Vance - Cape May Sunshine #11
Claudia Vance - Cape May Sunshine #11

Book

$ 14.99
Claudia Vance - Cape May Sunsets #13
Claudia Vance - Cape May Sunsets #13

Book

$ 14.99
Claudia Vance - Cape May Magic #14
Claudia Vance - Cape May Magic #14

Book

$ 14.99
Death Rents a Beach House book
Death Rents a Beach House book

Book

$ 16.95
Cape May Women's Cap - Natural
Cape May Women's Cap - Natural

APPAREL

$ 24.99
Cape May Men's Trucker Cap
Cape May Men's Trucker Cap

APPAREL

$ 24.99
Cape May Men's Trucker Cap - Surf Riders
Cape May Men's Trucker Cap - Surf Riders

APPAREL

$ 24.99
1000 Piece Cape May Lighthouse Puzzle
1000 Piece Cape May Lighthouse Puzzle

PUZZLE ADULT

$ 31.95
1000 Piece Cape May Lifeboat Puzzle
1000 Piece Cape May Lifeboat Puzzle

PUZZLE ADULT

$ 31.95
Cape May Lighthouse Notepad
Cape May Lighthouse Notepad

Paper goods

$ 12.95
Cape May Petite Notecards
Cape May Petite Notecards

BOX CARDS

$ 24.95
Sold Out
Cape May Horseshoe Crab Notepad
Cape May Horseshoe Crab Notepad

Paper goods

$ 16.95
Cape May Short Stack Notepad
Cape May Short Stack Notepad

stationary

$ 16.95
Arched Board with Cape May Lighthouse
Arched Board with Cape May Lighthouse

HOUSEWARES

$ 55.95
Artisan Board with Cape May Lighthouse
Artisan Board with Cape May Lighthouse

HOUSEWARES

$ 28.95
Bevel Board with Whale's Tale Logo
Bevel Board with Whale's Tale Logo

HOUSEWARES

$ 32.95
White Acacia Bevel Board with Whale
White Acacia Bevel Board with Whale

HOUSEWARES

$ 32.95
Whale's Tale Logo Coaster
Whale's Tale Logo Coaster

HOUSEWARES

$ 3.95
Whale's Tale Keychain
Whale's Tale Keychain

keychain

$ 7.95
Don't Be Crabby Magnet
Don't Be Crabby Magnet

MAGNETS

$ 9.95
Turtle Crossing Magnet
Turtle Crossing Magnet

MAGNETS

$ 9.95
Laughing Gulls Magnet
Laughing Gulls Magnet

MAGNETS

$ 5.95
Lighthouse Magnet
Lighthouse Magnet

MAGNETS

$ 5.95
Cape May Map Magnet
Cape May Map Magnet

MAGNETS

$ 5.95
Cape May Lifeboat Magnet
Cape May Lifeboat Magnet

MAGNETS

$ 5.95
Cape May Map with Coordinates Coaster
Cape May Map with Coordinates Coaster

Coasters

$ 9.95
Choose Something Fun Coaster
Choose Something Fun Coaster

Coasters

$ 9.95
Cape May Map Coaster
Cape May Map Coaster

Coasters

$ 6.95
Blue Cape May Lighthouse Coaster
Blue Cape May Lighthouse Coaster

Coasters

$ 6.95
Pink Cape May Lighthouse Coaster
Pink Cape May Lighthouse Coaster

Coasters

$ 6.95
Sale - Doug Salvatoriello 2025 Cape May Calendar
Sale - Doug Salvatoriello 2025 Cape May Calendar

CALENDAR

$ 7.00
Tied the Knot in Cape May Sign
Tied the Knot in Cape May Sign

WALL ART

$ 29.95
Cape May Lighthouse Kitchen Towel
Cape May Lighthouse Kitchen Towel

TOWEL

$ 12.95
Whale's Tale Logo Cape May Hat
Whale's Tale Logo Cape May Hat

APPAREL

$ 29.95
Adirondack Cape May Mug
Adirondack Cape May Mug

HOUSEWARES

$ 10.95
Claudia Vance - Cape May Raindrops #12
Claudia Vance - Cape May Raindrops #12

Book

$ 14.99
Whale's Tale 50th anniversary mug
Whale's Tale 50th anniversary mug

Mugs

$ 11.95
Petite Rainbow Bar Necklace
Petite Rainbow Bar Necklace

Jewelry, Necklace

$ 265.00
Rainbow Bar Necklace
Rainbow Bar Necklace

Jewelry, Necklace

$ 379.00
Claudia Vance - Cape May Glitter #15
Claudia Vance - Cape May Glitter #15

Book

$ 14.99
Robinson's New Thing
Robinson's New Thing

kids book

$ 19.99